Olivia Harper
In your experience, what causes a young person to be driven into a violent act?
I think that there are several considerations to take into account of why would someone be driven into an act of violence. Certainly socio and economic factors do come into play; however I think that given my experience working with juveniles involved in the Criminal Justice System; if there is a lack of any real parental influences from early on, this is of tremendous impact on a young persons life and lifestyle.
From early on in the life of a child, parental influence on a child is a key to a good up bringing. If the home is divided against itself, if there are no real boundaries, if there are no real consequences growing up; then there would be no thought given to acting out as a teenager in the community.
If a child is acting out, commiting crimes, or acting in a deviant manner, (especially of a violent nature) then there is reason for alarm. Certain behaviors should be monitored closely, and parents need to know the signs. Things like changing friends, changing habits (like dropping out of a sport or school program that they were once very involved with), changes in other behaviors that might appear odd or strange. Parents need to talk (I did say TALK) with their children daily about things that are going on with them, parents need to take the time to be involved (and stay) involved with their children.
I am not saying that because the household is a strong one, that kids will not go down the wrong path or head in the wrong direction; what I am saying is this; PARENTS need to take the first active role and actions within the care of their children. PARENTS need to be pro-active in knowing what their child is doing, where they are going, who they are spending time with and so-on. If both parents will assume this responsibility, and hold their child (or children) accountable for the actions they take (good and bad), punish them for wrong doings (appropriate and immediate punishment that fits the “crime”), and REWARD them for good and appropriate behaviors, there might be a better outcome.
Are parents at fault for not upholding moral values? What is your standpoint on moral values?
This is a compound question of great consequence. I think that parents should be held to that standard of and for upholding moral values, but then the question becomes whose morals and values? Do we look at the moral code and conduct that the world determines and often times dictates to us (all of us), and our children? Should we consider the values that the world and the media tell us are good, true, and right? I believe that parents should consider what is truly moral, and this starts with God and the Bible.
Train up a child in the way he should go, even when he is old he will not depart from it (Proverbs 22:6 NASB)
Parents want to ‘hand off’ the responsibility of raising their children to others; namely teachers, even church leaders, government officials and so-on. Parents need to and must take this active role and train up their children in a positive and loving manner, and discipline them (again appropriately and in a manner of love and concern) when necessary (Hebrews 12:11).
The answer to the question is this; YES. Parents should be responsible and held accountable for upholding and teaching morals and values to their children first and foremost.
After the Virginia Tech incident do you believe enough has been done to increase school security?
No. In my opinion, there can never be enough done to help ensure the safety and wellbeing of our children. Having said that, sometimes you can have plans in place, security evaluations and threat assessments for the ‘what if’ scenarios that you can never truly know if they will work, or even if they do work to what extent they are successful.
I believe that Virginia Tech had such measures in place to some level, but the problem you get into is this; the size of the school, the timeliness of the response from Law Enforcement or other trained professionals from the campus security teams, and the biggest issue that I can see is this – where is a person going to attack if this were to happen? Looking back at school shootings, it is always easy for someone to say what they would have done in that situation (Monday morning quarter backing), but that is looking back at it. It is easy to say that things went wrong or bad because of so-and-so, or this or that, but unless and until this ever happens to them, who really knows why things went bad?
Schools are a place of vulnerability, plain and simple. Schools are also increasingly becoming more and more violent. I think that most schools (Elementary through High School) have School Resource Officers (SRO), and this is a good place to begin. A security plan needs to be implemented in every school, similar to a fire evacuation plan, but with other factors to consider (such as an active shooter scenario, and not just where are we going to meet outside of the building in the event of a fire drill), other considerations are how many people are involved with this (one shooter, or more?), does the teacher know what to do in the event of a shooter, and are there safe zones in the school designed for containing the students? Another thing to consider is this; once a team (Law Enforcement) has been brought in, are there signs from teachers and school staff to let Law Enforcement know that they are alright? What I mean is physical signs posted somehow outside of the classroom or in a window somewhere to show L.E. (Law Enforcement) that they are all set?
Once a clearly outlined plan is developed and put in place, it needs to be practiced for it to be executed well. I am not talking about practice once a year and that is all, this needs to be done with frequency as well as done with surprise so that everyone will be able to perform it as if it were an actual event, not a drill.
If a child is a victim of abuse do you think that person will have a hard time breaking away from that lifestyle?
There are studies that suggest that if you are a victim of abuse, that this will have an effect on you to some extent for the rest of your life. I do not have those statistics, but I have seen the impact of child abuse on several people in the scope of my employment as a Law Enforcement Officer, and throughout the Court system.
Many people have been the victims of some type of abuse or another, and to whatever extent, this has affected (I would say) all of them. Some of them become abusers to their children and other children, some victims develop a deep sense of hatred towards their abusers, and become actively involved in groups fighting against abuse (New Hope for Women advocacy, Batterers groups, and so-on). I have observed people who are in psychological counseling because of abuse that has happened to them, and this is a lengthy process which often times involves the use of medication to assist in the process.
I believe that people who have been victims of abuse (whatever kind of abuse it may be) will carry it in some way for a very long time. I also think and have seen people who have been victimized, that do not do the same thing to others that was done to them. People are all unique, and can overcome abusive situations and environments with time, good support structures and people in place to help with the process of recovery.
Many girls are victims of dating violence. What do you think causes the boy to be so violent? Is there anyway of preventing this?
Domestic Violence is a problem in relationships involving people of all ages and both genders. Can domestic violence be prevented? Sure, there are many programs available that address issues from Anger Management to Drug Addition and Substance Abuse. These programs are designed to address the underlying issues that cause people to demonstrate poor impulse control. These learned techniques are designed to promote communication; “using your words” instead of opting for violence.
Do you believe that law enforcement officers should be required to take a course that teaches how to recognize abuse? Should this be mandatory in every state?
As certified Law Enforcement Officers we have mandatory trainings annually to maintain our Law Enforcement credentials and as such we are required to take trainings (in accordance and compliance with the Maine Criminal Justice Academy) that give us insight into certain behaviors, abuse being one of them. We also have a certain amount of hours that we are required to participate in elective trainings in order to maintain or eligibility as Law Enforcement Officers. I believe that most Officers take every advantage of trainings in order to better themselves and make certain that safety is a priority for everyone.
I think it should be mandatory in every state, and in fact I believe that it is. I also know that we have those requirements on a yearly basis; but that we also participate in several other trainings regularly to help us become experts in certain fields of Law Enforcement (D.R.E. or Drug Recognition Expert or Technician as Maine recognizes them (this is National not just with the state of Maine), Accident Scene Reconstruction Specialist, Active Shooter Specialist, Defensive Tactics and Training, etc). As part of my credentials as a Deputy, I am constantly going over all kinds of scenarios, and ways to make myself a better Officer, recognizing abuse is vital in any Law Enforcement Officers line of work, regardless of what they do or where.
Do you think teachers should be trained to handle violent situations between students? Why or why not?
There should be trainings on how to recognize certain behaviors that could potentially be problematic; however I am not certain I would encourage teachers to become involved within a violent situation or not. There are pros and cons for this issue; liabilities for the school and the teacher, any potential injury to the teacher or staff as well as the student(s), Should teachers assume this responsibility, or should this be the role of the SRO if there is one?
I do think that teachers (of all level - High School, college) need to have some crisis intervention skills and training. I do not know that it needs to rise to the level of stepping in between students who are fighting or not.
I do feel that most teachers would do the right thing, and would protect or defend another regardless of "obligation" or even "policy"....It may be viewed as a duty to protect. I think that most of us would come to the assistance of another if put in that position.
Teachers are there to instruct, and teach. I think that a part of that oath there is also insight given to the students about behaviors, attitudes, acceptable responses and reactions, and the like. This is a very important role, and teachers do this well. Parents still have the most important responsibility with their children, and that is giving them the tools they need to succeed, teachers help put them into practice as well. All of these things work together to help make certain that violent outburst do not happen (to the best of our ability), but I think that we cannot predict when and where it will happen, we just need to do our best at teaching others that it is never (NEVER) the answer...
We all have a role in that. We all can do our part.
A lot of abuse and bullying occurs on school buses. What would your advice to the driver be?
There should be individual policies and procedures on this issue, or some guidelines for what to do in specific instances.
I would tell my drivers to pull over in an area that is well traveled (for safety reasons for the driver and for other students), and I would instruct them to contact the Administrative District or their immediate supervisor or designee (a Dispatch center for the bus drivers should be in place or established) and let them know that there is a problem between students on the bus, (of a bullying nature or a potential explosive nature) and that they are near this road and that road (the corner of Broadway and Limerock). I would have them make contact with the parents of the students and let them know what is going on, and that the bus driver is turning back towards the school where they should come and pick up their child. A hearing date should be established for the future to discuss these issues, and what possible consequences they may be facing).
If the problem is not severe, the bus driver could directly handle it by giving the student a directive to follow as well as what the alternative would be if the order was not complied with. If that approach did not work, the bus driver could (again) pull over, separate the two or three people (or more) and take names down to later give to the Principal or counselors at the school to call the students involved in (with parents) to discuss this issue and what penalties there may be also.
Should violent people be punished or put into hospitals and taught how to behave? (Your opinion)
I think that this is a tough issue, the question of violent people and what is the best solution for them and for the communities. Some states have instituted the ‘three strikes’ and your out policy whereby it is a mandated sentence that the Judges have no discretion over. Maine has this type of mandate for certain crimes (OAS – operating after suspensions and other similar policies). I think that there are other answers for juveniles, or people with certain first offenses rather than jail or Department of Corrections (DOC), but for others (even if it is there first time in trouble) jail or DOC might be the only answer for them.
Part of our Justice system requires the consideration and safety of the public and the best interest of the communities where these “violent offenders” will be released into. Keep in mind that the Justice system has a several tiered approach to different aspects of the Judicial Branch; such as Bail considerations, alternative sentencing conditions, batterer’s workshops which may be mandatory in a sentencing analysis, and so-on. One of the approaches is a Rehabilitative view (can this person become a productive member of society or not?), another view is strictly Punitive (punishment – punishment – and more punishment, this person will never change his or her ways, so lock them up and throw away the key), and other viewpoints that combine both of these, or have a different approach altogether.
I think that people charged with violent offenses should be looked at in a couple of ways; first, the individual themselves and the circumstances; was this mutually combative, or was it a blatant act of violence? A second methodology would be to look at all of the crimes of the same nature, and look at punishments as well as recidivism (relapse into the same crime) while looking at similar types of rehabilitative services in place for those people (did the services work or not? Did the time in jail work or not?).
There are programs within the jails or DOC that are by nature rehabilitative. Depending on the length of your sentence, you (as the offender) will be able to participate in many programs designed to “rehabilitate” you and your tendencies.
Does it make sense to euthanize murders, or are there other alternatives besides life imprisonment?
The simple answer is; there are other alternatives to life in prison. I think that this is multifaceted and should be viewed in at least two ways; first, what is the cost of housing someone in prison for life? I believe the last statistic that I was made aware of was around $70,000 (plus or minus). This is a substantial cost to the tax payer, especially if the one facility holds 2000 people, and 400 of them are in for murder, the state would bear the cost of $28,000,000!! That is huge, and the state may have two or three facilities housing prisoners (those same prisoners have appeal rights, they also may commit new criminal conduct in the prison system and have to be transported to court to plea or plea bargain).
I think that another approach is answered in a question; what is the value of human life? Is one life more valuable than that of another? This of course does not help the families of the victims in these cases.
Some states have capital / corporal punishment for specific crimes of violence. If you are drag racing with a friend, and a child steps out of the curb where and when you happen to be racing, and you kill him or her, should this qualify for a death penalty? If you blatantly murder someone, and show no remorse over it, should this qualify you for the death penalty?
There may be options that I am not familiar with for offenders of this sort, but does it make sense to attempt to rehabilitate someone who will never see the outside of a prison? Does it make sense to take all the murderers and put them in a remote prison somewhere, or on an island?
I think that for now the states that do not have a death penalty (such as Maine) will continue to look at the options; and states that do have the death penalty will continue to deal with the protesters and supporters over such actions.
Maine did at one time have the death penalty for certain horrific actions against people, murder was one of these crimes (I think also that forcible rape of a brutal nature also qualified you). Maine abolished the death penalty sometime in the 1970s; I want to say 1976 because of a graphic nature of the last person that was sentenced to hanging. These were all public executions, so they were frequently packed with people watching. The last (or one of the last hangings) execution Maine held was very brutal. The man sentenced to death decided he would not be hanged, but instead attempted to kill himself in his cell overnight. The next morning when they came to get him, he was still alive. The Warden decided to have him dragged out anyways and hanged, where he lasted for several minutes.
Is this what we want? Are we so barbaric that this is the only way to solve our problems within the Criminal Justice System? I hope not, but crimes are increasing, violent ones are soaring, and the answers are getting fewer and fewer. Jails and Prisons are overcrowded; violence within the DOC and other jails is also increasing since the population in them is larger then ever before. I do not know what the answers are; only that things do need to change soon. There are other alternatives; we just need to look diligently for them.